Litigation by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations to enforce a subpoena for documents from Carl Ferrer, the CEO of Backpage, an online forum accused of contributing to sex trafficking, has taken another interesting twist, with the D.C. District Court ruling that Backpage cannot assert the attorney-client privilege to protect certain documents. It is rare for a court to issue a ruling on attorney-client privilege in a congressional investigation, and the court’s ruling has significant implications for any individual or company facing demands from Congress for documents, information, or testimony.
Continue Reading The Latest Twist in the Backpage Litigation and its Implications for the Attorney-Client Privilege in Congressional Investigations
Search results for: backpage
The Senate’s District Court Win in the Backpage Subpoena Fight Could Have Significant Implications for Congressional Investigations
Last week, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled in favor of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations in a rare case that has the potential to contribute significantly to the case law concerning congressional investigations. It is uncommon for a federal court to have an opportunity…
Continue Reading The Senate’s District Court Win in the Backpage Subpoena Fight Could Have Significant Implications for Congressional Investigations
The Congressional Agenda for March
Upcoming Congressional action for the duration of March appears likely to resolve the budget and appropriations impasse of the last several months. House and Senate leaders and the White House were able to reach an agreement last month on topline spending numbers for Fiscal Year (FY) 2018, which began last October 1, and FY 2019. This two-year spending deal will likely put an end to the months of partisan debate over defense and domestic spending caps following five short-term spending bills that led to two government shutdowns. The current stopgap spending measure (P.L. 115-123) expires on March 23, giving members just three short weeks to complete work on a $1.2 trillion omnibus bill.
The budget compromise provides for almost $300 billion in additional federal spending over the limits established by the 2011 Budget Control Act (BCA). House and Senate appropriators are now working to allocate the funds into the 12 annual appropriations bills and draft the legislation that meets the parameters of the agreement. Lawmakers hope to roll these 12 bills into a single legislative vehicle, an omnibus bill, that can pass both chambers before the March 23 deadline. It remains to be seen whether the spending bill could carry a number of controversial policy issues that remain unresolved, including gun control, immigration and border security, and health care, among other topics.
There have been discussions among the White House and congressional leaders about potential gun safety or other related legislation following Florida’s recent disheartening mass school shooting, but Republicans and Democrats are divided on what should and can be done. President Trump has indicated openness to an increase in the age requirement for buying rifles from age 18 to 21, a proposal to extend mandatory background checks to include sales at gun shows and over the internet, incentives encouraging the arming of teachers, and a ban on bump stocks or assault weapons. At least some of these measures would require departures from prevailing Republican orthodoxy. Under application of Senate rules, action there would require some bipartisan cooperation in order to achieve 60 vote thresholds on any of these measures. The Senate could also attempt to strengthen the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) to prevent criminals from purchasing firearms. Democrats support NICS legislation, although some conservative Senate Republicans have expressed due process concerns. A version of this legislation passed the House in December, but was paired with a provision providing concealed carry reciprocity to legal gun owners. It is unclear whether the House would take up the NICS legislation on its own. It is possible that less controversial gun or school safety measures could be incorporated into the omnibus spending package.Continue Reading The Congressional Agenda for March
House of Representatives Seeks to Strengthen Subpoena Enforcement Dramatically
In late October, the House of Representatives quietly approved a bill that would dramatically strengthen Congress’s procedures for enforcing congressional subpoenas. In adopting the bill, the bipartisan leadership of the House Judiciary Committee highlighted the challenges that Congress faces in obtaining materials from executive branch agencies. Significant portions of the…
Continue Reading House of Representatives Seeks to Strengthen Subpoena Enforcement Dramatically
D.C. Circuit Dismisses Major Case Concerning Attorney-Client Privilege in Congressional Investigations
The long saga of the legal challenge by Carl Ferrer, CEO of Backpage, to a subpoena issued by the Senate’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (“PSI”) appears to have reached a conclusion. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit this week dismissed the case as …
Continue Reading D.C. Circuit Dismisses Major Case Concerning Attorney-Client Privilege in Congressional Investigations
This Week in Congress – January 9, 2017
Republican leaders in Congress plan to take the initial steps towards repealing and replacing Obamacare this week, hoping to deliver on the campaign promises made by most Republicans over the past six years and by President-elect Trump during the 2016 election cycle.
Both chambers are expected to begin their consideration…
Continue Reading This Week in Congress – January 9, 2017
Supreme Court Refuses to Stay Senate Subpoena, Highlights the Difficulties Inherent in Challenging a Congressional Subpoena
The Supreme Court today refused to block a subpoena by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations of the online forum Backpage and its CEO Carl Ferrer. As we previously reported, Ferrer lost at the District Court in his effort to block the Senate subpoena, arguing primarily that the subpoena…
Continue Reading Supreme Court Refuses to Stay Senate Subpoena, Highlights the Difficulties Inherent in Challenging a Congressional Subpoena
This Week in Congress – March 14, 2016
It will be a busy week on Capitol Hill with the House returning from its one-week district work period and the Senate aiming to adjourn for its spring recess at the end of the week.
The Senate is scheduled to return to legislative business on Monday afternoon, with a vote expected at 5:30 p.m. on the nomination of Dr. John B. King, Jr. to serve as Secretary of Education.
The Senate floor agenda for the remainder of the week is unclear, although there are several potential bills the Majority Leader could seek to consider. The Senate may return to consideration of S. 2012, comprehensive energy legislation previously stalled by an amendment to provide emergency funding assistance to Flint, Michigan to assist with decontamination of the community’s drinking water system. Senator Jim Inhofe (R-OK), Chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, and Michigan Senators Debbie Stabenow and Gary Peters filed stand-alone legislation to provide federal assistance to address water infrastructure issues, including the Flint situation, and have been working with Senate leadership to negotiate a path forward.
Unfortunately, the deal being negotiated to bring both the energy and water-infrastructure bills to the Senate floor now appears to be held up by an amendment regarding offshore drilling. Senator Bill Nelson (D-FL) has placed a hold on the energy bill over an amendment proposed by Senator Bill Cassidy (R-LA) that would increase revenue sharing for states that allow offshore drilling for oil and gas in the Gulf of Mexico. While drilling authority is under the control of the federal government, a spokesperson for Senator Nelson said the financial incentive generated by the amendment would create “such immense pressure to continuously open up new areas to offshore drilling that it’d only be a matter of time before they’d start looking to open up areas off Florida’s coast.” Even though the energy bill managers and Senate leadership had hoped to wrap up the bill before the Senate adjourns at the end of this week for its spring recess, consideration will be stalled until the hold is resolved.
As negotiations continue on the bipartisan energy and water-infrastructure bills, the Senate may move to consider S. 2609, a food labeling bill sponsored by Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman Pat Roberts (R-KS). The legislation would prevent individual states from instituting labeling requirements for genetically modified foods and instead require that the Department of Agriculture set up a national voluntary standard of labeling for foods with genetically modified ingredients. So far Vermont is the only state set to require the labeling of genetically modified foods, although Connecticut and Maine have passed similar legislation that will only go into effect if neighboring states pass legislation. More than two dozen other state legislatures have introduced food labeling legislation in recent years. Proponents of the bill argue that a patchwork of state labeling laws produces an inconsistent national regulatory regime, allowing a handful of states effectively to set national policy, and adds expensive compliance costs which food companies will pass on to consumers, raising everyone’s food costs nationally. Opponents of S. 2609 believe that consumers have a right to know what is in their food. The House has already passed its own version of food-labeling legislation to prevent states from enacting labeling laws.
Another potential item for Senate consideration is S. Res. 377, a resolution to hold Backpage.com and its CEO Carl Ferrer in civil contempt for refusing to comply with a subpoena issued by the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. During the Subcommittee’s investigation of underage sex trafficking last year, a subpoena was issued to Mr. Ferrer requiring him to testify before a hearing and for Backpage.com, a classified advertising website, to provide relevant documents. The website refused to comply and Mr. Ferrer refused to attend the hearing, submit testimony, or answer questions. S. Res. 377 would authorize the Senate Legal Counsel to enforce the subpoena and conduct civil contempt proceedings.
Another item that may see Senate action this week is a measure to extend authorization and appropriations for the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The current authorization for FAA activity and funding is set to expire March 31. House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Bill Shuster (R-PA) introduced the Aviation Innovation, Reform and Reauthorization Act in February. The legislation would reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration and its funding until 2022, but the bill contains several proposals that are highly controversial, including a provision to privatize the country’s air traffic control system.
Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) unveiled a more modest proposal last Wednesday to reauthorize the FAA through September 30, 2017. The committee is scheduled to vote on its bill at a Wednesday markup, but a short-term extension will be necessary until both chambers can move legislation forward. A proposed short-term extension, H.R. 4721, the Airport and Airway Extension Act of 2016, introduced in the House last Thursday, will provide authorization of current FAA programs through July 15. The House is expected to pass the extension early this week in order to allow for Senate consideration before Senators adjourn for their recess at the end of the week.
Continue Reading This Week in Congress – March 14, 2016