If you are the general counsel of a Fortune 500 company, you might be excused if you express bewilderment in response to reports about the successes of U.S. “tort reform.” In the past 5-8 years, both the plaintiffs’ bar and governmental authorities seem to have added an extra digit to many mass tort and product lability claims, demanding nine or even ten figures—and sometimes securing such sums—for personal injury or property damage claims that previously would have yielded eight- or nine-figure results. To be sure, the injuries and damage in some cases are very substantial. But tort valuations have exploded in many cases where there is scant proof of serious injury or devastating damage and no loss of life, and even where the science may favor the defense on quantum.

Click here to read the full alert.

Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Allan B. Moore Allan B. Moore

Allan B. Moore practices in the areas of international arbitration and insurance coverage. He co-chairs the firm’s Energy Industry Group and previously co-chaired the firm’s Arbitration Practice Group for 10 years. Allan has served as lead counsel in some of the largest and…

Allan B. Moore practices in the areas of international arbitration and insurance coverage. He co-chairs the firm’s Energy Industry Group and previously co-chaired the firm’s Arbitration Practice Group for 10 years. Allan has served as lead counsel in some of the largest and most prominent insurance disputes of the past 15 years, helping clients recover more than $1.7 billion since early 2023 alone. Described by clients as “a wonderful lawyer” with “deep knowledge,” he “articulates positions clearly” and “focuses on the key issues” (Chambers). He was a runner-up for “Litigator of the Week” in The American Lawyer’s Litigation Daily in May 2020 for a victory for ExxonMobil, and he has been recognized as a leading lawyer by Chambers Global, Chambers USA, Best Lawyers in America, and The Legal 500.

Clients in major cases include Norfolk Southern, whom Allan has represented in connection with the East Palestine, Ohio derailment; BP, for whom Allan was lead insurance recovery counsel in the Deepwater Horizon oil spill litigation; ExxonMobil, Hertz, Komatsu, Merck, Plains All American Pipeline, Samsung, S&P Global, TotalEnergies, and Tyco Fire Products. Allan has served as lead counsel before federal and state courts and arbitral tribunals throughout the United States and for disputes in Europe, Canada, the UK, East Asia, the Middle East, Australia, and Africa. Allan has extensive experience with “Bermuda Form” arbitrations and has served as lead counsel for successful parties in ICC, ICSID, UNCITRAL, DIFC-LCIA, SCC, AAA, CPR, and ad hoc arbitrations, as well as in ICC expert proceedings. He also occasionally sits as an arbitrator.

Allan is a member of the Executive Committee of the Institute for Transnational Arbitration (ITA); a former Member of the LCIA Court; a peer-selected “Distinguished Neutral” for arbitration and mediation with the International Institute for Conflict Prevention and Resolution (CPR); a rostered arbitrator with the Institute for Energy Law (IEL); and a member of the CPR Council. He coaches law students in oral advocacy and is a frequent speaker on insurance coverage and arbitration topics.

Photo of Sonia Campbell Sonia Campbell

Sonia Campbell is a partner in the global Insurance Practice Group, based in Covington’s London office. On insurance coverage matters, Sonia acts exclusively for policyholders against insurers.

She specialises in acting for policyholders on insurance coverage issues relating to a variety of policies…

Sonia Campbell is a partner in the global Insurance Practice Group, based in Covington’s London office. On insurance coverage matters, Sonia acts exclusively for policyholders against insurers.

She specialises in acting for policyholders on insurance coverage issues relating to a variety of policies, including bankers’ blanket bond (BBB), commercial general liability (CGL), commercial crime/fidelity, cyber, D&O/E&O, employment practices, political risk, professional indemnity (PI), property damage and business interruption (PDBI), trade credit and W&I policies. She also advises on related global insurance programme and risk management issues.

Sonia is experienced in dealing with disputes in the English courts (all levels), in arbitration (LCIA, ICC, and ad hoc arbitrations, with a particular specialism in Bermuda Form insurance coverage disputes) and by way of ADR.

Sonia and her team focus on acting for policyholders in industries including Construction, Consumer Brands, Energy, Entertainment, Hospitality & Retail, Financial Institutions, Life Sciences, Manufacturing and Technology. In addition, Sonia has extensive experience of the reinsurance market and can act in disputes between cedants and their reinsurers.

The team is heavily involved in significant emerging and developing risks/coverage issues, including acting for clients involved in PFAS / “forever chemicals” litigation and associated insurance coverage issues. Whilst Sonia represents FTSE 100/global organisations, she also provides coverage advice for board members/senior executives involved in public/statutory Inquiries (Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry, UK Covid-19 Inquiry) and those subject to civil/criminal regulatory investigations and proceedings.

The team’s matters tend to be cross-border, which means Sonia regularly works with lawyers in other jurisdictions, including in a monitoring counsel role.

Photo of Jeffrey Davidson Jeffrey Davidson

A co-chair of Covington’s commercial litigation practice, Jeff Davidson represents the world’s leading companies in commercial, antitrust, and insurance coverage disputes. Clients have entrusted Jeff with some of their most important matters, calling on his strategic judgment, fierce work ethic, and creative problem-solving.

A co-chair of Covington’s commercial litigation practice, Jeff Davidson represents the world’s leading companies in commercial, antitrust, and insurance coverage disputes. Clients have entrusted Jeff with some of their most important matters, calling on his strategic judgment, fierce work ethic, and creative problem-solving. He has prevailed in multiple billion-dollar cases on motions and after trial. The American Lawyer has recognized Jeff as “Litigator of the Week” for his wins in major cases.

In a recent trade secret arbitration with $1.8 billion at stake, he obtained a complete defense win on behalf of a major pharmaceutical company. In a recent antitrust matter, he led the defense against multi-billion dollar claims asserted by a government enforcer to a successful confidential settlement. In a third recent matter, he obtained summary adjudication against four insurance companies in a $100-million coverage dispute. Jeff also litigated one of the foundational cases on the foreign application of U.S. antitrust law, obtaining a ruling eliminating a $3.5 billion claim shortly before trial.

Jeff also led a cross-office Covington team representing the University of California in its landmark challenge to the government’s rescission of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, obtained a nationwide injunction reinstating DACA, and successfully defended the injunction on appeal. In Regents of the University of California v. Department of Homeland Security, the Supreme Court agreed that the rescission was improper and set it aside.

Photo of Gretchen Hoff Varner Gretchen Hoff Varner

Gretchen Hoff Varner represents a wide range of companies in high-stakes coverage litigation and arbitration and has recovered hundreds of millions of dollars from insurers. She is a noted trial lawyer who has successfully arbitrated or tried multiple insurance cases. Chambers USA ranks…

Gretchen Hoff Varner represents a wide range of companies in high-stakes coverage litigation and arbitration and has recovered hundreds of millions of dollars from insurers. She is a noted trial lawyer who has successfully arbitrated or tried multiple insurance cases. Chambers USA ranks Gretchen as one of the leading insurance policyholder attorneys in California, and says that she is “an incredibly thoughtful and strategic adviser, a good counsellor, and is incredibly knowledgeable. She is also an excellent writer and communicator.” She was one of the Daily Journal’s 2017 Top 40 Under 40 Lawyers in California and Business Insurance named her as one of its Women to Watch for 2022. She recently secured a trial victory in New York State Supreme Court on behalf of her client Brooklyn Union Gas Company. She is the Managing Partner for the San Francisco office of Covington.

Gretchen’s trial work also reflects her commitment to public service; she led the Covington trial teams that overturned New York City’s racially discriminatory stop-and-frisk policy after a three-month trial in the Southern District of New York, and challenged unconstitutional conditions for mentally ill prisoners in a Mississippi private prison.

Gretchen represents policyholders with all types of insurance policies, and focuses on:

General liability insurance
D&O and E&O insurance, particularly related to securities claims
Cyber insurance, data breaches, and privacy-related losses
Property and business interruption insurance for catastrophic losses, including fires, hurricanes, and Covid-19
Trademark infringement and intellectual property losses
Environmental contamination and other long-tail liabilities, including product liability
Event cancellation
Bad faith, fraud, and violations of insurance regulations

Outside the courtroom, Gretchen is a trusted advisor to corporate decision-makers and has resolved multiple high-dollar matters without the need for litigation. She is often praised for her ability to translate complex insurance concepts into practical guidance.

She is a member of the American Law Institute, the past Chair of the Insurance Section of the San Francisco Bar Association, and a frequent speaker to industry groups and at conferences. A champion of women in leadership, she also serves on the board of the Girl Scout Council of Northern California.

Photo of Benedict Lenhart Benedict Lenhart

Ben Lenhart is a partner practicing in the areas of insurance and litigation. He serves as co-chair for Covington’s preeminent Insurance Practice Group. For more than 20 years, he has helped his coverage clients successfully resolve their insurance disputes. Ben believes that his…

Ben Lenhart is a partner practicing in the areas of insurance and litigation. He serves as co-chair for Covington’s preeminent Insurance Practice Group. For more than 20 years, he has helped his coverage clients successfully resolve their insurance disputes. Ben believes that his clients are best served by knowing how and when to use all of the tools available to resolve coverage disputes including settlement negotiations, ADR, and litigation. Using this balanced approach, many of his coverage cases resolve successfully with little or no litigation. He has been named as a leading lawyer by numerous ranking firms including Chambers USA (Nationwide), Legal 500, Best Lawyers in America, International Who’s Who, Washington DC Super Lawyers and PLC Leading Lawyers, and he is one of only a dozen policyholder lawyers nationwide included in the Legal 500 Hall of Fame. He has been a featured speaker at many leading insurance conferences.

Ben is often asked by clients to take the lead role in structuring insurance recovery strategies and negotiating settlements. He has been involved in over 500 insurance settlements and judgments covering the spectrum of liabilities, with individual recoveries ranging in size from under $1m to more than $500m. He has represented many policyholders in negotiating multi-party coverage-in-place or cost sharing agreements. His substantive experience includes: environmental claims, product liability claims, directors and officers (D&O) and professional liability claims, asbestos, business interruption, employment-related claims including discrimination claims and employee theft, mass tort, silica, hearing loss, repetitive stress injury (RSI), “dirty air” and natural resource damage (NRD) claims, fiduciary claims, including 401(k) and ERISA claims, catastrophic loss, and not-for-profit liability claims.

He has particular experience with Resolute and the London Market (having reached more than 100 settlements with these entities). He is deeply involved in UK solvent schemes of arrangement on behalf of policyholders. He was counsel to the successful objecting policyholders in the BAIC, WFUM and Scottish Lion solvent schemes, the leading cases in the solvent scheme arena.

Ben also has an active pro bono practice, most recently assisting low-income persons with disability insurance matters, helping Superstorm Sandy victims secure coverage for homes lost during the storm, and helping a small store owner recover insurance for fire losses.

Ben has taught Constitution Law at Georgetown Law Center for more than 20 years.

Photo of Cléa Liquard Cléa Liquard

Cléa Liquard is a seasoned and experienced commercial litigator who specializes in policyholder-side insurance coverage disputes. Cléa has played leadership roles on a number of high-profile coverage matters, including representing: McKesson Corp. in litigation with its general liability insurers to recover insurance for…

Cléa Liquard is a seasoned and experienced commercial litigator who specializes in policyholder-side insurance coverage disputes. Cléa has played leadership roles on a number of high-profile coverage matters, including representing: McKesson Corp. in litigation with its general liability insurers to recover insurance for opioid-related liability; the NFL in litigation against its general liability insurers to recover for concussion-related liabilities; a leading financial industry trade association in litigation under an event cancellation policy for COVID-related cancellations; a foreign manufacturer for product recall coverage; a well-known hedge fund on numerous claims under investment management liability policies; a credit rating agency for 2008-era financial crisis liability under E&O policies; a household-name media company in recovering under a multimedia lability policy; and a leading sports league to secure coverage for antitrust, media, and other liabilities. Cléa has extensive experience securing favorable recoveries under D&O, E&O, General Liability, Rep & Warranty, and Media policies for a broad range liabilities and losses, including shareholder actions, mass tort, and professional liability claims. Cléa has successfully recovered hundreds of millions of dollars on behalf of her clients. She also works closely with clients and brokers on coverage advisory and placement issues.

Cléa’s commercial litigation experience also includes ongoing representation of a pension fund in arbitration and litigation against its investment manager, and acting as defense and settlement counsel in product liability litigation.

Cléa is active in the New York City Bar Association’s Insurance Law Committee, where she has been an invited panelist on past and upcoming seminars on D&O insurance coverage issues.

Photo of Colin Watson Colin Watson

Colin Watson is a partner in Covington’s market-leading insurance recovery practice, where he litigates insurance coverage disputes for policyholders and counsels clients on insurance-related issues.

Colin has acted in state and federal courts around the country, as well as in confidential arbitrations, and…

Colin Watson is a partner in Covington’s market-leading insurance recovery practice, where he litigates insurance coverage disputes for policyholders and counsels clients on insurance-related issues.

Colin has acted in state and federal courts around the country, as well as in confidential arbitrations, and has pursued coverage for a range of underlying liabilities, including mass tort, pollution, product defect, consumer protection, antitrust, and shareholder claims. He also has significant experience with first-party property and business interruption losses. Colin has handled disputes arising under a variety of coverages, including CGL, D&O, commercial property, BPL, technology E&O, pollution, event cancellation, fiduciary liability, and the Bermuda Form. He has helped obtain hundreds of millions of dollars for clients in multiple industries, including energy, asset management, custodian and investment banking, consumer finance, financial technology, real estate, healthcare services, and sports.

Colin has been recognized by Business Insurance as a leader in the insurance and risk management sectors and has served as a member of the editorial advisory board for Law360’s Insurance Authority: Specialty Lines.

Earlier in his career, Colin litigated a broad range of commercial and non-commercial disputes involving, among other things, securities fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, anti-competitive conduct, false advertising, trademark infringement, and employer negligence.

Colin also maintains an active pro bono practice, representing individuals, including veterans, in a variety of unpaid matters. As part of his pro bono practice, Colin regularly supervises client intake reviews for the Mid-Atlantic Innocence Project. Previously, Colin was one of only ten recipients of the New York State Bar Association’s Access to Justice Award, for his contributions to public service. Colin’s pro bono work also earned the firm the Hon. J. Clarence Herlihy Award from Prisoners’ Legal Services of New York.

Colin is a member of the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors of the Council for Court Excellence, a non-profit, non-partisan civic organization that works to enhance the justice system in the District of Columbia.

Within the firm, Colin has served as the summer associate program’s litigation assignments coordinator, been active in new attorney integration efforts, and presented CLE on a number of litigation topics. Before relocating to Washington, Colin practiced in the firm’s New York office for several years.