On May 4, 2021, the European Commission rejected the UK’s application to join the Lugano Convention. Whilst the Commission’s Communication is advisory only, it seems likely that both the Parliament and the Council (with whom the final decision lies by qualified majority) will follow the Commission’s lead.
Although the Convention may seem a rather abstract technicality, it is in fact an important legal tool, allowing for the cross-border application of civil and commercial law with practical implications for issues such as child maintenance in family law and facilitating international legal action for smaller companies.
What is the Convention?
The 2007 Lugano Convention is an international treaty concluded between the EU and three of the EFTA States. A new State may join the Convention if its request to do so is approved by all contracting parties, but the competence to agree to the accession of a new Party lies exclusively with the EU.
The Lugano Convention is a so-called ‘Double Convention’ Treaty in that it not only governs international jurisdiction questions, but also the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgements in civil and criminal matters. Through this mechanism, the Convention gives legal certainty to businesses which operate across borders.
How Did it work for the UK as a Member State?
The EU’s original jurisdiction and enforcement treaty was the 1968 Brussels Convention, signed by France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Luxembourg and Belgium. The first Lugano Convention was signed in 1988 by the then 12 members of the European Community and the then six members of EFTA who were not eligible to sign the Brussels Convention. The 1988 Lugano Convention was superseded by the 2007 version. For EU Member States, considerations of jurisdiction and enforcement are governed by the Brussels (Recast) Regulation 2012.
As a Member State of the EU, the UK legal services sector had gained significant value from the Regulation (and before it, the Convention), since they facilitated the UK being the chosen legal venue for legal disputes involving companies from across the EU. Recognizing this value, the UK applied to accede to the Convention on 8 April 2020 as a third country outside the EU – the importance of accession was increased by the absence from the EU-UK TCA of a chapter on civil legal cooperation.
Continue Reading The Lugano Convention and The UK
