Photo of Abby Rickeman

Abby Rickeman

Abby Rickeman is an associate in the firm’s Washington, DC office. She practices in the employment, institutional culture and social responsibility, and public policy groups. She also maintains an active pro bono practice.

Contact:Read more about Abby RickemanEmail

With the 119th Congress now assembled, Republicans control both the House and Senate, and will control the White House starting on January 20th.  If history is any guide, this change in party control of the White House, plus unified control of Congress by the president’s party, will pave the way for Republicans to deploy the Congressional Review Act (CRA) to overturn a number of regulations issued by the Biden Administration.  When President Trump first took office in 2017, congressional Republicans used the CRA to overturn more than a dozen rules promulgated by the Obama Administration.   

The CRA mandates federal agencies to submit all final rules to Congress before the rule takes effect.  Then, Congress has 60 days to overturn a rule by enacting a joint resolution of disapproval that withdraws the rule and prohibits the agency from issuing a rule that is “substantially the same.”  However, if a rule is submitted to Congress within 60 days before adjournment, the CRA’s “lookback period” allows additional time—a new 60-day period—for the new Congress to review the rule and introduce a resolution of disapproval.  If a rule has already taken effect when a CRA resolution is signed into law, the rule “shall be treated as though such rule had never taken effect.” 5 U.S.C. § 801(f). 

Although the House and Senate parliamentarians make the official determination of whether a particular rule falls within the lookback period when a disapproval resolution is introduced, the Congressional Research Service estimates that rules submitted to Congress on or after August 1, 2024 are likely subject to possible nullification. The CRA allows members of Congress to introduce resolutions of disapproval starting on the 15th day of the new session. Under the current congressional schedules, Senators may introduce CRA resolutions starting around January 23, 2025, and Representatives may introduce CRA resolutions starting around February 5, 2025.

Many federal agencies operated under an earlier deadline and thus prioritized finalizing and submitting high-priority rules this spring—including those “significant rules” defined in Executive Order 12866, as amended by Executive Order 14094, that are predicted to have an annual impact of $200 million or more on the economy.  Because these rules were submitted earlier, they will likely fall outside the CRS’s estimated CRA lookback window.  The George Washington University Regulatory Study Center estimates approximately 100 of these significant rules may fall into the CRA window, which is likely fewer than in prior changes in administrations, in part due to early agency action.  However, there are more than 1,000 rules that could ultimately be subject to disapproval under the CRA in the new Congress.    Continue Reading Biden Administration Rulemakings at Risk for Congressional Review Act Cancellation in New Congress

As discussed in our prior post, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) issued a final rule earlier this year that increased the salary thresholds required to classify certain employees as exempt from overtime pay requirements under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).  On November 15, 2024, the federal district…

Continue Reading Federal District Court Vacates Biden’s DOL Overtime Rule

With the 2024 election rapidly approaching, the Biden Administration must race to finalize proposed agency actions as early as mid-May to avoid facing possible nullification if the Republican Party controls both chambers of Congress and the White House next year. 

The Congressional Review Act (CRA) allows Congress to overturn rules issued by the Executive Branch by enacting a joint resolution of disapproval that cancels the rule and prohibits the agency from issuing a rule that is “substantially the same.”  One of the CRA’s most unique features—a 60-day “lookback period”—allows the next Congress 60 days to review rules issued near the end of the last Congress.  This means that the Administration must finalize and publish certain rules long before Election Day to avoid being eligible for CRA review in the new year.

Overview of the CRA

The CRA requires federal agencies to submit all final rules to Congress before the rule may take effect.  It provides the House with 60 legislative days and the Senate with 60 session days to introduce a joint resolution of disapproval to overturn the rule.  This 60-day period counts every calendar day, including weekends and holidays, but excludes days that either chamber is out of session for more than three days pursuant to an adjournment resolution.  In the Senate, a joint resolution of disapproval receives only limited debate and may not be filibustered.  Moreover, if it has been more than 20 calendar days since Congress received a final rule and a joint resolution has not been reported out of the appropriate committee, a group of 30 Senators can file a petition to force a floor vote on the petition.   

If a CRA resolution receives a simple majority in both chambers and is signed by the President, or if Congress overrides a presidential veto, the rule cannot go into effect and is treated “as though such rule had never taken effect.”[1]  The agency is also barred from reissuing a rule that is “substantially the same,” unless authorized by future law.[2]    

Election Year Threat: CRA Lookback Period

These procedures pose special challenges for federal agencies in an election year.  If a rule is submitted to Congress within 60 days before adjournment, the CRA’s lookback provision allows the 60-day timeline to introduce a CRA resolution to start over in the next session of Congress.

This procedure ultimately requires the current administration to assess the threat of a CRA resolution against certain rules and determine whether to issue the rule safely before the deadline or risk a potential CRA challenge. Continue Reading Congressional Review Act Threat Looms Over Biden Administration Rulemakings

Today, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) unveiled a new bipartisan proposal to develop legislation to promote and regulate artificial intelligence. In a speech at the Center for Strategic & International Studies, Leader Schumer remarked: “[W]ith AI, we cannot be ostriches sticking our heads in the sand. The question…

Continue Reading Senator Schumer Unveils New Two-Part Proposal to Regulate AI